Anger over school bus cash cuts
HUNDREDS of children could be left without transport following moves to axe school buses in Exeter.
Cash-strapped Devon County Council plans to cut seven subsidised buses used to take children to and from schools in the city.
Two secondary schools and a primary will lose services under the cutbacks.
The council claims the dedicated routes for pupils not entitled to school transport are only provided for 'historic reasons' and are not a service it has to maintain. But parents, teachers and councillors say they are shocked at the plans.
From April 8 the council will stop the 970, 971, 972 and 976 services going to St Peter's, the 973 to West Exe Technology College and the 981 and 982 to St Nicholas School.
Parent Steve Grant, who lives in Cowick, has a child at St Peter's and another due to start in September. He said: "I think is it appalling. It is going to cause terrible problems for many who live on this side of the river.
"It will not be good for children to travel on public transport and have to change buses in High Street. Nor will regular travellers be too happy with suddenly finding four bus-loads of children travelling on their buses."
Exwick mum Mandy Heggadon, who has two children at St Peter's, said: "This would mean it will take them longer to get to school. It is too dangerous for them to cycle on the dark winter mornings.
"We want them to be able to go to St Peter's without having to worry about transport."
Mark Perry, headteacher at St Peter's Church of England Aided School, said: "It looks very concerning at the moment but I am urgently seeking a meeting with the county council to see if there are alternatives.
"I do have concerns that people in the middle of an academic year may have to amend travel plans significantly.
"They are changing a system that brings children safely on to the school site and then takes them home again. I appreciate that there have to be cuts, but I regret the timescale with changes due to start at the beginning of the summer term."
Angela Folland, acting headteacher at St Nicholas', said: "We have children aged three to 11 who travel from all over the city to our school to receive a Catholic education. Cutting this subsidy may well mean parents are less able to make this choice for their children and will mean more traffic on the roads. As part of our planning permission we had to meet stringent traffic reduction figures and have actively encouraged our children to use the school bus service.
"We are working with the Diocese to explore other options to enable our children to get to school safely while minimising the increase in traffic."
Rob Hannaford, county councillor for St Thomas and Exwick, said he would be challenging the decision at the Exeter Joint Highways Committee tomorrow.
He said: "At peak commuter times many of these bus routes are already standing-room only, so what on earth will happen? Many parents will simply drive their children across the city.
"Bizarrely the bus to St James will be kept because it's not funded from the same budget."
Laura Newton, city councillor for Exwick, said: "I am concerned about the safety of children who will end up walking long distances and also the impact on the roads and environment of more cars."
A spokeswoman for the county said: "Devon County Council is having to find £54.6m savings from April. These school buses are currently providing a service for children not entitled to transport provided by the county council.
"The majority of pupils not entitled to subsidised transport have to make their own way to school. But a minority who are not entitled have been provided with subsidised transport for largely historical reasons.
"We have approached the schools and offered them help in tendering and/or setting up contract management processes if they wish to continue these arrangements themselves."
The county was yesterday unable to give a precise figure on how much money the cuts would save, but it is expected to be in the thousands.









34 Comments
View all
by Janet, Exeter
Tuesday, February 08 2011, 11:43AM
“I agree entirely with David Smith of Exeter when he says that when the schools were re-built a new one should have been provided to serve the children of Exwick instead of having to pay to bus them across the City since West Exe Technology College cannot take them in as it is not large enough!!! I did ask Devon County Council several years ago if another school could be built but was informed that it was due to a falling birth rate and lack of children able to attend!! Now we are seeing the problems that this is causing with a lack of High School provision on the West side of the City where I live and yet more and more houses being built. When will something be done about it before it is too late and we see all but a handfull of children being taken to school by their parents - cars clogging up the roads because there is no High School for them to go too.”
by John, City Centre
Monday, February 07 2011, 8:59PM
“So perhaps the CofE and RC should charge rent to DCC for the provision of the schools land etc and use that to subsidise the buses?
Why is it that some always feel the need to moan about Church schools forgetting that without the input from the Church the schools would not exist and it would cost DCC even more!”
by Richard Adams, Exeter
Sunday, February 06 2011, 12:18AM
“I agree with many of the comments made. Please keep running the buses and charge riders a suitable fare, which ought not to need a subsidy.
I'd be astonished if Jimmy is correct , though, when he says that
"...by removing the subsidies on the St Peters routes will save Devon council tax payers £330,000 per year."
Kids only attend school for about half the days in the year, when you take holidays and week-ends into account, which if he's right would mean the buses cost £2,000 per day to run. I suspect the saving will only be perhaps half this sum. Still, a useful saving.”
by What's your poison?, Exeter
Saturday, February 05 2011, 10:07PM
“Legal
Not really
Why should a Christian child not be 'average'?
Keep digging, you're good at it.”
by legal, exeter
Saturday, February 05 2011, 6:30PM
“Poison
For 'normal' read 'average'
Dioes that help?”
by David Smith, EXETER
Friday, February 04 2011, 11:30PM
“AFTER spending millions of pounds to rebuild schools across the city, albeit to resemble prison camps, why on earth wasn't a new school built within easy access of Exwick.
The present policy of students travelling across the city is a waste of time and money and some of the students don't like travelling on the unsupervised buses because of poor behaviour.
A whole generation learn how not to behave on public transport!
....”
by What's your poison?, Exeter
Friday, February 04 2011, 7:12PM
“legal
"Normal children are turned away"
So church-going Christian children are 'not normal'?
That must be a borderline comment, even for you”
by legal, exeter
Friday, February 04 2011, 6:48PM
“Bored
1. How do you know exactly what happens in the classroom at the school - are you a teacher?
2. I know DCC provide the buses, but why should they as it is a non LA Woodard School.
3. The majority of the pupils are selected because they are CofE and regularly attend church.
4. Normal children are turned away.
5. The parents chose to send their children specifically to this school so why should Devon taxpayers be expected to fund individual choice.
6. The simple solution is to send your children to a nearby school.”
by Simon D, Exeter
Friday, February 04 2011, 11:24AM
“Bussing kids from one side of the city to the other doesn't make sense, much better to build another secondary school within walking distance of Exwick!!”
by TurtleHead, MyWhole
Friday, February 04 2011, 10:08AM
“I HATE cheese”