City drivers pay more for fuel without Asda

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

MOTORISTS in Plymouth pay an average of 3p less a litre for fuel than those in Exeter because the naval city has an Asda supermarket, the Echo can reveal.

Previously disparities between fuel prices in the region could be attributed to distance from oil processing plants and seasonal variations.

Now prices are dictated by Asda's pricing policy, with petrol stations near one of the supermarkets forced to reduce prices to remain competitive.

Without an Asda, petrol station owners are able to make more on their fuel.

Yesterday Morrisons, in Prince Charles Road, Beacon Heath, was selling the cheapest unleaded, at 114.9p a litre.

Yet the same supermarket was selling the fuel for 2p less in Yeovil and Plymouth.

Exeter's Pinhoe Sainsbury's was selling unleaded for 114.9p, while at the Alphington Road branch it was 115.9p. Sainsbury's stores in Plymouth and Yeovil were selling it at 112.9p.

The average price for unleaded was in Plymouth was 114.2p, in Exeter it was 3p more, at 117.5.

Industry analysts say the reason for the lower prices in Yeovil and Plymouth is because both have an Asda, which was selling unleaded at 112.9p.

The supermarket chain — owned by Walmart — introduced a low-price guarantee this year which sets a maximum price store bosses can charge for fuel, but allows them to reduce it to match the lowest local price.

AA fuel price analyst Luke Bosdet said the presence of an Asda was increasingly important in driving down prices, and he was aware of drivers in Devon unhappy with the discrepancies.

"Having a Morrisons can be helpful but prices are not guaranteed to be the lowest," he said. "Asda has a national pricing policy — either it has a set price or a cap — but if they have a competitor charging less they can go below that price.

"What we have also seen is the other supermarkets can be very slow to react to a reduction in the wholesale price of oil."

He said the AA used to see an increase in the prices charged in the Westcountry during the summer, but this now appeared to be a thing of the past.

Mr Bosdet said he had been in contact with an AA member who was incensed by the price of fuel at the M5's junction 30 services. The driver said the Esso was charging 10p a litre more than he was charged by his local garage in Hampshire.

"There are still huge discrepancies and it is something people rightly feel strongly about," he said.

Spokesmen for Morrisons and Sainsbury's said their pricing was based on a response to local market conditions.

An Esso spokesman said there were different types of Esso, only some of which were entirely owned and operated by the company.

3
Tweet this article
Report

3 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Cynic, Exeter

    Saturday, July 31 2010, 5:59PM

    “Jane - See if you can spot the clue at the link below. A different area but the game's the same/similar.
    http://www.thisisexeter.co.uk/news/Proposal-300-homes-submitted/article-2472165-detail/article.html”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by jane, Exeter

    Saturday, July 31 2010, 3:04PM

    “I'd love to have an Asda here and not just because of their fuel prices. They're heaps cheaper than the other supermarkets, that's why I get my shopping delivered by them. Not much chance of it happening 'tho. It's fairly obvious that the likes of Tesco and Sainsburys must be dishing out some serious backhanders to the planning department people .”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by John B, Exeter

    Saturday, July 31 2010, 1:49PM

    “Why are we surprised, the only Supermarkets the Exeter Council allow to develop in Exeter is Tesco and Sainsbury. Competition, you must be joking!! Asda, Waitrose and Morrisons have made numerous applications to the Council only to be refused. Morrisons had to resort to purchasing the old Leo's (Coop) in Prince Charles Road and what a marvelous job they have made with it and given the Exeter citizen somwhere else to have a "choice". That said, the Exeter council will still not pass application from anyone other than Tesco and Sainsbury. Have you noticed what is happening in Exeter of late? Tesco in Cowick Street, Tesco in Exwick, major extension development at Sainsbury Alphington causing traffic chaos. I wonder what price is being paid for this "preferential" treatment???
    It is now a joke, Exeter is changing its name in 2011 to Tesco Fidelis.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters