Exeter amputee trapped in home
AMPUTEE Dave Braithwaite says he has become a prisoner in his home after being told he will have to pay for a stair lift.
Mr Braithwaite, 57, of Bernadette Close, Whipton, had his left leg amputated below the knee in January after suffering from septicaemia.
While at the Royal Devon & Exeter Hospital, where the operation was carried out, he said he was told by social services that he would be eligible for a stair lift for his first-floor flat.
He was also given a statement of need which called the stair lift “necessary and appropriate” and under a section headed degree of urgency, he was put in the danger category.
But Mr Braithwaite has just been told he cannot have one unless he pays the £2,000 cost.
The University of Exeter night security worker, based at the St Luke’s campus in Heavitree Road, was told he and his wife of 38 years Jane, also 57, a catering assistant at the university, earn too much to be eligible for a stair lift from social services.
But the pair have no savings and claim they are being penalised.
Mr Braithwaite said: “I was told I need a stair lift and that I would get one. But nobody said I had to pay for one.”
The decision by Mr Braithwaite to return home, where his wife presently cares for him full time, was made because he thought he would be getting a stair lift. He said: “I got sent home on Monday, February 22, which was my birthday.
“I said I wanted to come home thinking a stair lift would be fitted.
“But the next day, social services said it was means tested and because I am being paid by the university I am earning too much money so we have to pay for it all — and the price is £2,000.
“It is like a prison sentence — I am housebound.”
His next hospital appointment is on Monday, March 22, meaning he will have been housebound for a month.
He added: “If I had been told I might have to lose my leg in advance, I could have planned for it. But I didn’t know.”
Mrs Braithwaite said: “It was a nasty shock.
“If they had left him a few days more it could have been his whole leg or could have gone further.”
Mr Braithwaite is on full pay from the university for six months and will be on half pay for six after that. But he said he and his wife have no savings after filing for bankruptcy in 2007.
Mr Braithwaite, who praised the doctors and surgeons at the RD&E, said he had been told it could take up to nine months to get him back to full working order, probably through the use of a prosthetic limb.
A Devon County Council spokesman said: “A disabled facilities grant is offered to applicants who are unable to meet the cost of an adaptation.
“This is means tested using a national scale set by central government.
“For anyone who is not eligible for a disabled facilities grant, we investigate other sources of funding such as the major adaptations panel, who reassess the circumstances and may be able to offer financial support such as an interest free loan.”













9 Comments
View all
by t.c., N.C. (usa)
Monday, March 15 2010, 1:53PM
“some of you people need to get a grip. this man has gone through something very big and needs some help. i to know what he is going through i lost both of my legs above the knee and can not get any help from the govt. here in the states. i can not work. only help from friends are keeping my wife, two kids, house and i going through all of this. just be nice and help the man out please.”
by yawn, mars
Sunday, March 14 2010, 10:00AM
“I see my last comment was censored... typical from a city like Exeter ! housebound eh ! ... Mr Braithwaite you have NO IDEA what being housebound is mate... try a lifetime of it !”
by babooshka, Exeter
Saturday, March 13 2010, 5:37PM
“well, i'm sorry i have no sympathy for Dave.. and i'll tell you why .. I have been disabled since i was one ( from Polio) i've been in a wheelchair all my life and never had the opportunity to work, now i am 50 years old and as a registered disabled person it took me 7 years to get a nhs power chair so that i could access the outside world on my own .. and this chair is dangerous, unstable, underpowered and non negotiable.. because i, on a means tested income am supposed to use my high rate of DLA for 1) a motability car 2) the adaptions thereof 3) the tax and insurance of vehicle 4) the fuel 5) adaptions of my home 6) payment for home helps ie cleaners ... This Dave has an amputation below the knee of one leg.... try living an entire lifetime in a wheelchair in this society .. whinging people make me sick ! i've raised 3 kids and not once have i had the intervention or help from social services or any other body of people ... get on with your life Dave Braithwaite...!!”
by steve, Exeter
Friday, March 12 2010, 5:43PM
“I'm with you Pete, why should I pay for this poor fellow's stairlift? If my taxes go up any more I'll be off abroad. Yes Andrew taxpayers money needs re-distribution though....less 7 bed houses for big families...less guns and bombs...less benefits for the workshy...more teachers...doctors etc etc”
by Mrs Barker, Exeter
Friday, March 12 2010, 3:37PM
“Well said Andrew. I totally agree. Its such a shame this hard working couple are being treated in such a way. If they were jobless chavs the council would have had the stair lift fitted before he left hospital. Its about time the people who actually pay taxes get a little something back.”