Exeter bouncers launch CCTV cuts protest
DOOR staff are launching a campaign against plans to cut CCTV coverage in the city after claiming it could lead to a big increase in violence.
Bouncers at Exeter’s nightspots have rallied together to condemn the proposed cuts and claim the move could have a drastic effect on levels of crime and violence in the city centre.
-

Jim Myers
As previously reported in the Echo, the plans have been proposed by cash-strapped Exeter City Council in a bid to balance its budget.
The authority wants to slash positions within the city’s control room — saving around £50,000 a year.
But Jim Myers, chairman of Exeter’s Door Supervisors’ Association, said: “The council wants to save around £50,000 a year but when it comes to a life, how much does a life cost?”
Police and councillors have already expressed concern at the controversial plans.
They claim the move could affect the force’s ability to solve and prevent crimes.
And the city’s most senior police officer, Superintendent John Vellacott, has called for “careful consideration” before the service is scaled down.
Now doormen are looking to gather thousands of signatures in opposition to the proposals as the deadline for the decision draws closer.
Mr Myers said: “The CCTV system is a godsend to door staff and things are running very smoothly in the city.
“Reducing staff in the control room will have a drastic effect; there will no doubt be an increase in violence and crime. But we won’t know the full impact of the cuts until someone gets hurt.”
Mr Myers, who works at The Angel, in Queen Street, said cutting CCTV would be putting both doormen and the public at risk. “I was disgusted when I heard about the plans to reduce staff in the CCTV control room,” he said.
“Taxpayers have paid a lot of money to have a good system introduced and it needs to be used to its full extent. The amount of incidents it has helped to solve is huge.
“A lot of doormen are very concerned about these proposals — both for their own safety and for that of the public.”
Fellow door supervisor and city councillor Marcel Choules has said he will sign the petition.
“Every part of the city centre is monitored by CCTV, particularly at weekends. Door staff rely on the CCTV 100 per cent, especially when there is disorder in pubs, or when doormen or members of the public get assaulted. The CCTV picks it all up,” he said.
“We are putting a lot of people at risk by cutting it. It has been successful in solving and preventing stabbings, rapes, robberies and muggings.
“That needs to be taken into consideration when deciding whether to cut manpower in the control room.
“I will be signing the petition and I agree with what Mr Myers is saying.”
And Councillor Ruth Smith, the city’s Deputy Lord Mayor, has pledged her support to the campaign.
“I think the door staff in the city have a difficult enough job and they need the back-up of the CCTV,” she said.
“I’m very concerned about these cuts and, in actual fact, there are areas of the city where more coverage is needed.
“This is a quick fix option and I’m sure that a more in- depth study would show other areas where cuts could be made instead of in the CCTV control room.”
Mr Myers said a number of names had already been added to the petition.
“We launched the petition on Friday night and we’re gathering names from other door staff, customers and anyone who happens to be passing,” he said.
“It has gone very well so far. We hope to gather as many signatures as is humanly possible over the next couple of weeks.”
Reductions to CCTV staff is just one of a raft of cost-cutting measures proposed by the council to meet budget constraints.
Final discussions on the budget will take place at a meeting of the full council on Tuesday, February 23.











18 Comments
View all
by pat, plymouth
Wednesday, February 17 2010, 6:08PM
“Simple, contract services out to the private sector!”
by Lu, Exeter
Tuesday, February 16 2010, 11:34PM
“Like I've commented before and ill comment again on this subject. If we had a decent council that knew how to spend our moneyh properly we wouldn't have this argument. We need CCTV it saves lives and convicts scumbags on our streets. As a regular clubber the amount of incidents I have seen we do need our cameras. Terry dare what if you or a member of your family were attacked and there were no cctv? you would be wishing it was there to catch the thugs who did it!”
by rosalie c, exeter
Tuesday, February 16 2010, 7:52PM
“i agree with rachel, i hope the likes of terry dare never need the back up cctv or the whinging door staff when he is looking for help. no one is immune to trouble, having cars damaged, or slapped in the face in an unprovoked attack..”
by nicola, cullompton
Tuesday, February 16 2010, 7:47PM
“without the cctv there would never have been a conviction in the brutal attack of the exeter woman found under a van nearly dead, also wasnt it " door supervisors " who came to the aid of a royal marine years ago who was savagely attacked in the city centre??? Mr dare wants to remember these things when he reads about such attacks and has a nerve to shake his head at the state his city has become. Door supervisors are there for protection, cctv is there for protection they go hand in hand, and is very much needed in todays society.”
by rachel, tiverton
Tuesday, February 16 2010, 7:15AM
“As a door cronie- or should i also spell it croinnie..myself, i find terry dares comments insulting and may i add, if he ever finds himself in a situation where he needs the help of either a" door croinne", or needs the evidence of cctv, i hope he finds neither is available to him, and i hope not to read any more stuipd comments from him in the express and echo for at least three months....the cctv is an invaluable source to the safety of the city,and is as much needed as the door supervisors. may i suggest a night without either?, i will then look foward to your comments mr dare!”