Exeter incinerator campaigners await decision

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

CAMPAIGNERS are  anxiously awaiting the  decision on whether a  multi-million pound incinerator for Exeter will  be given the green light.

Following a public  consultation, the Environment Agency said  the decision on whether  to issue a permit for  what has been described  as a “non hazardous  waster incinerator” to  be built off Grace Road  on the Marsh Barton Industrial Estate was “imminent”.

The agency said it was   waiting for  final information and clarification  from Viridor Waste  Management, which  will run the site,  and  said it could make its  final decision public as  early as today.

Campaigners, who are  hoping to stop the facility being built, say it a  potential environmental  disaster.

 They had 20 days to  register their concerns  up until October 26. The  representations have  been collated and considered and Mike Dunning of the Environment  Agency said they have  all been taken on board.

He said: “We are still  considering the responses and a decision is expected any day now. We  just need a little more  information from Viridor. There has been a  good response. It has  taken time to go through  it very carefully and  take on board the issues  and concerns that have  been expressed.

“If we had made the  decision we would not  be requesting additional  information from Viridor. We take our role as  regulators very seriously. Any decision we  make is robust and  based on sound information and we will make  everyone aware of why  the decision was taken.”

The scheme was first  considered  in 1997 when  the original incinerator  closed.

 It returned to the  agenda in 2007 when the  Echo revealed the county council proposal for  the £32m scheme.

Despite a demonstration by Exeter Friends of  the Earth outside County Hall, the incinerator  was granted planning  permission in July, 2007,  when it was announced  construction work could  begin as early as summer 2008.

 Campaigners hoped it  had “quietly gone away”  until recently when it  was announced that  Viridor Waste Management, which will run the  plant, and the county  council were going  through the tendered  submissions for the contract to build it.

 The incinerator would  burn waste at high temperatures with the energy used to generate  electricity.

Campaign co-ordinator Maurice Spurway,  was behind the original  petition that attracted  more than 4,000 signatures.

He said: “The situation is probably more serious than it was when  we were first campaigning.

 “It is far more important to chase ways of  dealing with waste in as  low carbon a way as possible.

 “An incinerator is certainly not low carbon.”

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Dave, Exeter

    Thursday, November 19 2009, 7:39PM

    “Maurice Spurway says ¿An incinerator is certainly not low carbon.¿
    Well landfill produces large quantities of methane, which is several factors worse for so-called Global Warming than CO2. The amount of pollution from these modern plants is a fraction of what the old-style ones produced. This plant will also produce electricity, which otherwise would be produced from fossil fuel. You can't have it all ways MR S.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by MIKE E, exeter

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 3:31PM

    “great news jobs for exeter should never have been closed in the first place”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by T A Griffin, Exeter

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 1:24PM

    “I would like to see the Strategic Sustainability Assessment for this incinerator, I do not think that one has been done.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by T A Griffin, Exeter

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 1:18PM

    “with so much waste now being recyclable where is the waste which is to go the incinerator going to come from.

    The actual site is not fit for purpose. It could well be subject to flooding. Access to the site is not acceptable, and although the operator may well be Viridor, it was Devon County Council which obtained the permissions.

    I do not consider that this project is sustainable. Where is the assessment as to the sustainability of this whole project.

    We know that Exeter is increasing its greenness by the recycling. Will 'stuff' which is in the green bins going to be burnt? Will stuff be brought in from other parts of Devon to feed this behometh. It must not go ahead, it is not good enough.

    A new road is having to be built at great cost to give access to the lorries, it is bad enough that Exeter has a meat rendering plant, do not pollute the air of Exeter any more than it already is.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by brin, Exeter

    Wednesday, November 18 2009, 10:20AM

    “I believe that this proposed incinerater would probably have an effect on those enjoying a drink and some food with their children, on a sunny day at the Double Locks Hotel. It does not only affect those that live near to Marsh Barton, I had to move from Alphington after advice from my GP for health reasons and that was 7 years ago. This area was polluted and full of toxic gases back then (higher incidence of childhood asthma already in this area). This I am sure will only make things worse. If this is really needed, then they should find a more appropriate site, as this is a "green" area and needs to stop being built on and expanded further and further into the countryside near peoples homes and places of work.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters