Exeter man left dying by drinking buddies

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, January 14, 2009
Profile image for This is Exeter

This is Exeter

THE heartbroken family of a city builder who died after drinking a recreational drug have heard that he may have survived if friends had come to his aid sooner.

Father-of-three Nigel Cotter, of Wonford, was left unconscious by his drinking buddies for almost one and a half hours outside Drakes Wine Bar in Fore Street, Topsham, an inquest was told.

Witnesses had said his drink may have been spiked.

He died at the Royal Devon & Exeter Hospital after an ambulance was finally called.

Mr Cotter's wife, Gillian and his daughter, Katie, 24, wanted the police to investigate the incident.

But the inquest heard yesterday that the circumstances of the tragedy will not be subject to a criminal investigation after the Crown Prosecution Services ruled that there was "no case to answer".

The Exeter and Greater Devon coroner, Dr Elizabeth Earland, in an unusual move, had earlier adjourned the hearing and referred it to the CPS on suspicion it was a "case of gross negligence".

When the inquest resumed, and after the CPS had confirmed its position, she recorded a verdict that Mr Cotter died of non-dependent volatile substance abuse, contributed by neglect, suggesting that his life may have been saved if his friends had taken action sooner.

"He collapsed and remained in an alleyway before an ambulance arrived," she said.

"Remedial treatment was sadly not in time to save his life."

Mr Cotter's family say they remain "devastated" by what happened.

His wife Gillian and his daughter, Katie, speaking after the inquest said: "Nothing has come of this and the coroner said it was in part neglect by my dad's friends.

"My mother and I are disappointed that the CPS is not going ahead. Friends left him for nearly one and a half hours before help arrived.

"In our view they should have been held responsible.

"My dad might have survived if the ambulance had been called to the pub earlier.

"The thing is that his friends will be out again enjoying themselves tonight, but dad will not."

Mr Cotter had been drinking on the night of November 24, 2006, and witnesses told how he was seen to pick up a bottle of isobutyl nitrate — a recreational drug which is popular among clubbers and normally snorted, and is known as a "popper".

Some reported how Mr Cotter was seen to pick up the bottle containing the drug and drink it "in one" and the inquest heard his drink could have been spiked.

The coroner read out a statement about the drug provided by Peter Streete, head of toxicology at Guy's and St Thomas Hospital in London.

He said people reacted differently to it and it could prove fatal to some within 20 minutes or two hours.

The CPS was unavailable for comment.

8
Tweet this article
Report

8 Comments

  • Profile image for iainthavingit

    by iainthavingit

    Wednesday, June 22 2011, 2:06AM

    “Some reported how Mr Cotter was seen to pick up the bottle containing the drug and drink it "in one" and the inquest heard his drink could have been spiked.

    Pick up the bottle? A father of 3, likely in his 50's just 'found' a bottle of 'poppers' ? 'Witnesses say he could have been spiked?' Let's get some answers here. The inquest obviously had statements regarding spiking of this man's drink too. Yet no investigation was undertaken? I say re-open this case and get some answers for the family who not only have had to cope with the death of their loved one but also the trauma of how it happened.”

  • Profile image for iainthavingit

    by iainthavingit

    Wednesday, June 22 2011, 1:43AM

    “Is anyone going to answer Alexis? 'As quoted:'No papers were subsequently submitted to us for review. We have written to Mr Cotter's family to explain this to them.' As said by Tracey Easton, CPS. What papers weren't submitted and by whom? It seems the CPS/police have a case to answer. Who specifically didn't submit relevant papers?The Coroner states negligence may have caused the death of this poor man.”

  • Profile image for iainthavingit

    by iainthavingit

    Wednesday, June 22 2011, 1:25AM

    “Hmmmm....you are out drinking with your friend who passes out unconscious...what is you're knee-jerk reaction? To wait an hour and a half before calling an ambulance? But it's not just you; there are several of you...yet you all wait an hour and a half??? It's a human reaction to seek help in this situation yet it was not. Why not? There are questions unanswered here.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by ALEXIS, EXETER

    Saturday, January 17 2009, 7:58PM

    “IS TRACY EASTON, THE CHIEF CROWN PROSECUTOR SAYING THE POLICE DIDN'T DO THEIR JOB HERE AND INVESTIGATE PROPERLY?”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Tracy Easton, Exeter

    Friday, January 16 2009, 10:53AM

    “It is for the police to investigate and decide whether a crime has taken place. The CPS will then review and advise on the case when it is submitted to us by the police and decide whether a prosecution should be brought. In this case, therefore, the request to the CPS by the coroner for the case to be reviewed was forwarded to the police as that was the appropriate procedure. No papers were subsequently submitted to us for review. We have written to Mr Cotter¿s family to explain this to them.
    Tracy Easton
    Chief Crown Prosecutor, Devon & Cornwall”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Derek, Exeter

    Wednesday, January 14 2009, 6:29PM

    “One wonders where the papers on this case have been between November 2006 and January 2009? Possibly in someones "too difficult" tray, whilst the family wait!”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by natalie lester, exeter

    Wednesday, January 14 2009, 2:54PM

    “my thoughts r with katies family.... went to school with her years ago. he was a great bloke.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Jon, Exmouth

    Wednesday, January 14 2009, 12:38PM

    “My condolences to the family. With friends like that who needs enemies!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters