Exeter pay to park at work tax plan
CONTROVERSIAL proposals to charge staff for parking at work have been suggested as a way of cutting congestion and reducing carbon emissions.
The move could see thousands of workers, who currently enjoy free parking, affected by the charge if it is introduced in Exeter.
And employees at large city companies including the Met Office, EDF Energy and South West Water could be on the hit list.
The proposal is part of a range of ideas to help the city reduce its carbon footprint over the coming years.
Senior officers at Exeter City Council claim there are almost 18,000 “free” parking spaces for workers which could be levied as a way of managing congestion.
But they admit the proposals are controversial and have described them as uncomfortable in a report due to go before the authority’s executive committee next week.
The document sets out the city council’s proposed contribution to Devon County Council’s Local Transport Plan for 2011-16.
Exeter’s Chamber of Commerce has voiced concerns about a workplace parking levy being used to raise revenue.
And businesses in the city have reacted cautiously to the proposals, with some saying they already have measures in place to encourage workers to use alternative ways of travelling to work.
But environmental campaigners have thrown their weight behind the suggestions, claiming that radical measures are needed to curb climate change.
In his report, John Rigby, director of economy and development at the city council, said: “Uncomfortable though it is, a pricing mechanism in the form of a workplace parking levy is an effective means of managing demand — and thus without that congestion will continue.”
He told the Echo that parking charges would not be just another form of taxation and promised that the revenue raised would be ploughed back into improving the city’s public transport.
“The Government has been encouraging authorities to look at this as part of a package of transport measures,” he said.
“The introduction of workplace charging requires both the district and county councils to support it and the Government has to approve a scheme. If approved, it would be mandatory.”
He was cautious about the reactions from employers and workers,
He said: “I would be surprised that if they were asked about paying for parking as just a form of taxation, many people would be enthusiastic.
“But if, however, the money raised was ploughed back into public transport improvements, public opinion surveys suggest that significant numbers of people would support it.”
Derek Phillips, chairman of Exeter’s Chamber of Commerce, said the move would have to be part of a much wider traffic management programme.
He said: “We have always said that we would not necessarily be supportive of such a move but we would want to know the full implications.
“Traffic management in the city is important. If this was part of a package which would give benefits we would look at it but we need to know what benefits there would be if a workplace parking levy was to be implemented.
“It should not be introduced as a revenue raiser though. It should be part of a scheme to control congestion in the city.”
Exeter City Council currently charges its staff between £1 and £1.50 a day to park at Dix’s Field car park.
A spokesman for the council said: “Since the introduction of the Green Travel Plan, there has been a marked reduction in the use of the Civic Centre car park, with more staff travelling to work by bus, train or bicycle.”
Helen Chivers, spokesman for the Met Office at Sowton, said: “We have a lot of people who already car share and we have buses which run through the site. We are also close to the park and ride.
“We encourage people to use alternative modes of transport — that was one of the things we set up before we moved to Exeter.”
A spokesman for EDF, at Exeter Business Park, Sowton, said: “We haven’t seen the report so we can’t comment. EDF Energy has a very good track record at reducing the number of cars on the road and is working towards reducing carbon emissions from its transport fleet by 20 per cent by 2012.
“We have a green travel plan for Exeter and close to half the parking spaces at our Gadeon House office are used by car sharers. We also encourage staff to use public transport and provide incentives for motorbike and bike users.”
And South West Water, at Pynes Hill, said it also encouraged its staff to use other modes of transport other than driving to work.
Maurice Spurway, of Exeter’s Friends of the Earth and a founding member of campaign group 2020 Vision Exeter, has given the proposals his support.
“We need to start doing some fairly radical things to stop climate change,” he said.
“2020 Vision Exeter has written to the members of the city council’s executive committee to suggest that this a very important report which we wholeheartedly support.
“What we believe needs to happen is a fairly concerted effort to engage the whole community in a vision and action plan to deal with an interim target of 45 per cent reduction in CO2 emissions by 2020.
“We completely support the suggestion of a workplace parking levy.
“It would be a downward pressure in using the car to go to work if you know it’s going to cost money.
“It might discourage people to use their car for commuting. Also, it will raise money — we reckon about £4m a year because there are quite a lot of those workplace car parks.”
And Martyn Goss, chairman of Campaign for Better Transport, said: “We have been saying for a long time we need carrots and sticks to encourage people to not use cars and dissuade them from using them inappropriately.”
He said if workplace charging was implemented, it would need to be coupled with better public transport provision.
He added that the move, if implemented, may be vital for the city’s economic growth.
He said: “If Exeter wants to grow economically and bring more people in, then there needs to be new ways as capacity on the roads is extremely limited.”
The proposals will be discussed at a meeting of the council’s executive committee next Tuesday.









49 Comments
View all
by Andrew Colman, Exmouth
Monday, February 15 2010, 9:18AM
“I work at the Met office and see workplace parking tax as an excellent idea.
We all have to pay taxes somehow to pay for schools, hospitals etc so why not tax pollution”
by James, Exeter
Friday, February 05 2010, 12:21PM
“This seems like another way to generate more tax from the general public, as people will not stop driving to work if there is no other means/convenient way to get there.
Surely a simple solution is to restrict the hours you can park at council car parks in the city centre, so that they are not full up with workers cars who don't need to park in the city centre and this would create plenty of parking for who car parks are intended for 'the shoppers' and this would then in turn reduce the congestion around peak times for commuters who have no other choice but to drive in and out of the city on business.
The other major issue is the traffic created around schools by children being dropped off along with illegally parked parents, can kids and parents not use there legs these days!
The schools should have green travel plans imposed on them by the council to reduce pollution around schools to make it safer for the kids travelling to school and to encourage walking to school for a healthier future, as at the end of the day this is the next generation which will be the main force behind any changes in the future!”
by brin, Exeter
Friday, February 05 2010, 11:01AM
“I find it interesting looking through the above comments and some good points are raised.
But, please has anyone any idea why the majority of the office staff and non-frontline staff, are not working from home on PCs? I am pretty sure all of the mentioned companies could let maybe 50% of their workforce do this. This would cut down on the need for parking, it would ease congestion and have an impact on carbon monoxide levels in the city, so again, why not?”
by worried, sandford
Friday, February 05 2010, 9:58AM
“I live on the outskirts of crediton and if I am forced to pay for car parking at my job I would have to consider finding other employment as I am unable to get to work on public transport and therefor would be penalised”
by Kevin, exeter
Friday, February 05 2010, 9:23AM
“Why not charge people who take work vans home,as presumably they would be exempt from this charge.This may encourage some to use public transport and also free up thousands of parking spaces on housing estates everywhere, evenings and weekends.Have a count of all the parts vans etc on the roads in the morning,I wonder how many use them for private mileage at weekends without paying tax also.There are people in our street who are close enough to walk to work but all bring work vans home evenings and weekends and no one else can park as they have their own cars as well and of course the vans are always outside somebody else's house.”
by Helen, Exeter
Friday, February 05 2010, 8:07AM
“People will do what alot of staff at the hospital, they will just park on the steet closest to there place of work, residents will complain, the council will put in resident parking only, residents will have to pay for this, the council will generate even more money!”
by Richard, Exeter
Friday, February 05 2010, 7:16AM
“"Exeter City Council currently charges its staff between £1 and £1.50 a day to park at Dix¿s Field car park"
Oh, boo hoo. One rule for them, one for everyone else. How many years is it going to take them to introduce a public transport system to take people to and from work at the beginning and end of the day?
An example: It's been 6 months since Stagecoach stopped coaches loading and unloading passengers in the coach station. The coucil is still 'negotiating' with them and all the while, Exeter has just 2 coach bays for use by private coaches. Not good for business, but, hey, there are so many agencies to negotiate with, so many people to consult with, so many meetings....
It's a tax, pure and simple.”
by Robbo, St Davids
Friday, February 05 2010, 3:55AM
“This looks like an excellent way to drive off the type of investment that has made Exeter so successful in recent years. Needs a rethink maybe?
Also, righteous cyclist "mr ten years younger", nice to see your honest admission that you're not bothered by red lights, presumably because you ignore them. Make sure you carry a donor card please.”
by Dave, Exeter
Thursday, February 04 2010, 10:39PM
“Excellent idea. There are too many cars on the road.
But if you really want to make a difference and get people out of their cars then PLEASE PLEASE create more better and safer cycle lanes.
I would love to cycle to work but won't with the current conditions the roads are already in, the amount of cars on them and the brain dead people in them!”
by concerned voter, Exeter
Thursday, February 04 2010, 9:50PM
“This is yet another example of the Council leaders being ignorant of local opinion and needs. I've never known a time in all the years I've lived in Exeter when the City Council has been so out of touch with the views of the community of the city. The current elected members, predominantly Liberal Democrats, have no idea what the people of this city value and how to address their needs. We never see this lot except when you want our votes, and these stupid ideas and your embarrassing u-turns over them will be your undoing.”