Exeter trust advert defended

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Profile image for This is Exeter

This is Exeter

 CHARITY bosses have defended their decision to advertise a job for gay, lesbian and bisexual applicants only.

The Intercom Trust has been criticised for “discriminating” against job seekers because of their sexual orientation.

But the city organisation, which provides support for gay, lesbian and bisexual people across the South West, claims the position requires someone with experience of gay and lesbian issues.

The advert on the trust’s website  is for a community helpline worker and administrator to work full-time at its city office. It states there is a “genuine occupational requirement” for the successful applicant to be lesbian, gay or bisexual.

The organisation has received a complaint about the advert.

But executive director Dr Michael Halls said: “This position for a helpline worker and administrator requires the person to answer the helpline and speak to people who have often suffered terrible emotional damage. If someone has spent years and years of their life desperately hiding from all of their family something they know will have them thrown out, they want to speak to someone who is sensitive to the issues of being gay or lesbian.

“And if they find themselves speaking to someone who is straight they may close down in the conversation.

“They need to speak to someone who understands from the inside.

“It is the same thing for a women’s rape crisis helpline for example — the callers, who are traumatised enough, don’t want to talk to a man.

“We cannot risk someone who hasn’t grown up with being gay or lesbian to possibly give the wrong response and we want people to feel like they can call the helpline for support.”

“We had an angry voicemail message left by a woman who said she wanted to call us to account. I would have liked to have spoken to her but she never called back.”

In an email to the Echo, a jobseeker wrote: “I find this offensive that the advert is being specific about a person’s sexual orientation.

“I have no desire to enter into any exchange of opinions as I do not have a problem with whatever any person is or believes, if it be religion, race, colour, disability or sexual orientation.

“It is just that I am looking for a job in administration and found it amazing that I have to be something which is so specifically personal and nothing to do with my ability to do the job in order to apply for that post.”

A spokesman for Foot Anstey solicitors in Exeter, said: “Under normal circumstances, refusing to offer an individual employment on the basis of their sexual orientation would constitute direct discrimination.

“However, an employer may have a defence to a discrimination claim if they can demonstrate that it is a ‘genuine occupational requirement’ of the job that the post holder is of a particular sexual orientation.”

10
Tweet this article
Report

10 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Jon McKenzie, Plymouth REC

    Friday, March 12 2010, 9:31PM

    “In limited situations, it may be lawful for an employer to discriminate if there is a genuine occupational requirement for the jobholder to be of a particular sexual orientation.

    Example
    A charity delivering domestic violence services to lesbians, bisexual women, gay men and transgender people advertises for a gay caseworker to deliver services to its gay clients. The post is restricted to gay applicants because the charity believes that a particular sexual orientation is a genuine occupational requirement for the post. The charity considers that heterosexual men would not have an in-depth understanding of the cultural and domestic violence experiences of gay men. The charity restricts other caseworker posts to lesbian and bisexual women and transgender people for the same reasons. Other posts that do not require this kind of in-depth understanding, such as administrative posts, are open to people of all genders and sexual orientations. This type of discrimination could be lawful.

    http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/your-rights/sexual-orientation/when-is-sexual-orientation-discrimination-lawful/genuine-occupational-circumstances/”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Smiffy, exeter

    Friday, March 12 2010, 1:16PM

    “I do understand peoples point about discrimination but I am a lesbian and agree that unless you have been in a position where you are being looked at because you love the same sex or that your not ¿Normal¿ then how can you possible understand when someone is crying down the phone because they have lost their friends/family because they are gay. I lost most of my friends when I came out and would have love to have had support like this.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by Gea Vox, Bristol

    Thursday, March 11 2010, 5:24PM

    “The comments of Gribble, K Martinez or Anon, Devon totally illustrate WHY the posts advertised qualify for exemption under the Employment Equality (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2003, section 7.2.

    Thank you for making the point so very crystal clear!

    Q. E. D.!!! LOL!”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by K. Martinez, exeter

    Thursday, March 11 2010, 2:37PM

    “This is against the law. Action would be soon taken if it was white male only for an organisation that represents white males.”

  • Profile image for This is Exeter

    by steve, Exwick

    Thursday, March 11 2010, 2:00PM

    “Sam -

    Are you suggesting that everyoe who works or volunteers for Childline, FRANK or MacMillan has either had a "bad childhood", is a former drug-user, or has cancer?

    I can understand why ChildLine might want people with personal experience of abuse; why FRANK might want to employ people with personal experience of drug use to support others going through similar problems; and why personal experience of cancer might be viewed as a positive assett by a charity which supports people with cancer.

    What I don't understand is why you seem to be hostile to the idea that personal experinece matters.

    ....or is there something else arousing your hostility?”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article