Film shows another side of hunt debate

Trusted article source icon
Monday, May 10, 2010
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

COLIN Richey covers a number of points in his recent letter on hunting with dogs, More important issues than hunting, April 24. Rather than respond to each one individually as has been done on countless previous occasions, I merely refer readers to the amazing activities of one woman. In November 2005 a tiny hamlet in the heart of the Cotswolds was overrun by snarling hounds. Nisa Ward was out with her elderly neighbour.

A deer hurtled out of the woods pursued by the baying pack. As the villagers stood there helplessly the deer was caught. It screamed piteously as the dogs ripped it apart.

Shocked by her own experience and appalled to discover the number of horrific hunt-related incidents affecting ordinary members of the public all over the country, Nisa set out to discover the truth about hunting.

She travelled thousands of miles in her quest and has now produced a film, entitled A Minority Pastime, to expose the devastating human cost of hunting.

The film was previewed by MPs in the House of Commons in November of last year and screenings are now being held across the country.

Mr Richey describes a hunt as a 'social day out'. For a rather different view readers should log on to www.aminoritypastime.net. DVD copies of the film may be obtained by emailing nisa@aminoritypastime.net.

It is a manifesto commitment of the Conservative Party to allow a free vote, in government time, to repeal the Hunting Act 2004. Should a majority of MPs be in favour, then this particular form of animal abuse will become legal again. Readers may find out how candidates for election in their constituency would vote by logging on to www.keepcrueltyhistory.com

Ivor Annetts,

League Against Cruel Sports Tiverton

9
Tweet this article
Report

9 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by nina johnson, penzance

    Wednesday, May 12 2010, 10:25AM

    “Sarah, you obviously thoroughly enjoy following the hunt and feel very passionate about it but I am against all cruelty to animals and I do find it impossible to understand why anyone would enjoy seeing a wild mammal fleeing for its life from a big gang of humans, dogs and horses and then be ripped apart, or dug out of its hiding place by terrier men who set their dogs upon it. There is no justification for it at all and it is not a quick death. Hounds do not kill foxes instantly with a 'nip to the back of the neck'. Canids do not kill in this way but rather tend to bring down their prey by a series of bites and tears to their quarry. Post-mortem evidence from veterinary surgeons support that this is how foxes have died. the film shows hunt followers cheering and whooping for joy when the fox is caught which is really disturbing.
    The documentary also features a woman in cornwall who's elderly cat was torn apart and disenbowelled in front of her by out of control hounds who invaded her garden in 2009. Incidents like these happen all the time across the country and I find it abhorent and completely unacceptable. But hey its fun for afew people so who cares about the rest of us who are adversely affected.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Independent, Exeter

    Tuesday, May 11 2010, 9:59PM

    “Surely this issue comes down to this: what pleasure do you get from chasing and killing a wild animal?

    Surely you can have just as much fun by dressing up in your hunting clobber and charging around the countryside on your horse. Why the need to kill something?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Sarah, Surrey

    Tuesday, May 11 2010, 6:22PM

    “OK I've now seen the video clips - and the images of the fox being killed confirms my opinion - it's not pretty, but it is quick. A fox that dies slowly of poison probably looks quite pretty but that only makes the viewer feel better, not the fox.
    As for the hounds being killed on the railway line, I wonder if that was the infamous occasion when hounds were lured across by hunt saboteurs. I have seen this myself - hounds hunting on one side of the railway and a line of saboteurs, several with horns and the rest calling, trying to get them to cross in front of the train. I complained to police who agreed that this was happening but they didn't have the manpower to stop it or arrest the perpetrators.
    No I don't "enjoy" seeing an animal killed, in 35 years of following hunts on horse and on foot I have only seen it once - the Saturday before the ban came into effect, so it's never been an incentive.
    If you feel the way you do about hunting, what on earth do you feel about prawn sandwiches where dozens of animals are killed fairly horribly, by boiling, just for the pleasure of tasting their flesh?
    I return to my original point - if the anti hunt cause has to rely so heavily on tainted evidence, how can you believe any of it?
    In February 2006 Ms Ward said she did not see the supposed hunted animal, did not know what species it was and did not find its body. In November 2007, describing the same incident, she said a deer was killed in front of her and a group of witnesses. Both these accounts cannot be true, the question is why on earth did she feel it necessary to change the story?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Donald Plimsole, Exeter

    Tuesday, May 11 2010, 2:29PM

    “What about all the gnats and mosquitoes that are routinely slaughtered at dusk every day by murdurous motorists driving along at more than 5mph ?? Surely we should limit cars to 5mph to stop this evil genocide !”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Paul, Exeter

    Tuesday, May 11 2010, 9:45AM

    “Sarah, have you seen the video clips in the letter, are you suggesting that they are false?

    Rather than make a point of what originally was or not seen could you tell me why you seem to support the activities shown in the film?

    Is it really fun to see an animals killed in this way?

    Do you enjoy seeing animals being killed in this way?

    Is this Sport?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Sarah, Surrey

    Monday, May 10 2010, 7:58PM

    “... and it DOES matter whether she saw the deer or not, since she now claims she did.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Sarah, Surrey

    Monday, May 10 2010, 7:55PM

    “My point is a little bit of, erm, exaggeration seems to be going on. She said one thing shortly after the incident, she said a completely different thing a bit later on when she had a film to promote. If your objections to hunting are formed on false information (if that is what is happening here), then surely you should make an effort to find out the truth. It may change your mind.
    Anyway, if the deer really was killed in that way (and Ms Ward was unable to discover whether one had been killed at all in the first version of her story) it was neither according to the sport of fox hunting (since it was a deer) or stag hunting (where the animal is shot), but an unintentional accident. If it happened at all - Ms Ward said (in February 2006) she was unable to determine even what species of animal had been killed, her only evidence being something that she thought was a smear of blood.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Paul, Exeter

    Monday, May 10 2010, 5:55PM

    “Sarah, and your point is?

    It does not matter one iota whether she saw the deer or not it is still a disgusting activity to kill animals in this way and call it SPORT.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Sarah, Surrey

    Monday, May 10 2010, 1:19PM

    “This wasn't quite what Ms Ward described at the time. When she first complained about this incident in February 2006, she told the local and national press in many interviews that she saw a pack of hounds in private woodland opposite her house cross into another private plantation, from where she said she heard screaming which "might have been a fox or a deer". Later, after they had gone, she went into the woodland and discovered bloodstains but no body. It wasn't until November 2007 that she claimed to have seen a deer being chased before being killed in front of her and others. Hmmm....”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters