Lib Dems in U-turn over Exeter toilet closures
CAMPAIGNERS are celebrating after people power forced a U-turn from the city council over its plans to close more than a third of Exeter’s public toilets.
In the face of widespread outrage at the proposal to shut 10 toilets in the city, the council has announced the measure will be dropped from its proposed budget when its executive committee meets next week.
Since the launch of Save Our Toilets campaign in the Echo nearly two weeks ago, support from all sectors of the community has been overwhelming. More than 500 coupons in support of the campaign have been sent in. Hundreds of these were handed to the council leader Adrian Fullam ahead of an executive committee meeting a week ago, but these pleas were initially ignored as members voted to include the toilet cuts in the draft budget.
But with pressure continuing to mount, the Liberal Democrat administration confirmed yesterday it would formally withdraw the closure programme when the executive meets again a week today.
The news prompted scenes of jubilation outside one of the saved toilets in Blackboy Road, that was only rebuilt at a cost of £110,000 five years ago.
The other toilets that have received are reprieve are Buddle Lane, Okehampton Street and Cowick Lane in St Thomas; Ennerdale Way in Exwick; Hamlin Lane and Higher Cemetery in Heavitree; and King William Street, Musgrave Row and Guinea Street in the city centre.
The savings of £60,000 now look set to be made by reducing the current provision for next year’s pay award for local government workers from one per cent to 0.7 per cent. While discussions are still on-going at national level about public sector pay, the Local Government Employers has proposed a freeze for the next financial year.
Defending the way his Liberal Democrat council has handled the situation, Cllr Fullam said: “We put all the information out early for discussion on a whole range of cuts and the biggest reaction we got was the toilets, so we have reflected and reacted on it.
“This has shown we have listened and acted on what we have heard. We have very difficult decisions to make and all the areas where cuts are made people are not going to be happy.
“We have listened to feedback from residents in the Echo, on websites and those who have contacted us directly
“We had to be careful as if we reacted to every objection and reversed all cuts we would end up bankrupt but we did not hide anything.
“Making cuts is an emotional process and I would rather be seen as performing a U-turn than being stubborn and arrogant. If we did not make the right decision the first time round it is only right we should change our minds.”
His Liberal Democrat colleague Cllr Kevin Mitchell confirmed that plans for an all-party working group to look into the future provision of public toilets in the city would continue with a view to looking at a “community toilet scheme”.
This would see shops, restaurants and pubs open up their facilities to be used by members of the public.
He said: “It is envisaged that the general public, including those organisations and members of the community who were concerned about the toilet closure proposal, will have the opportunity to play a key part in this review.”
Opposition councillors welcomed the decision and praised the Echo for its role in bringing about the change.
Leader of the Labour Group for the city council Pete Edwards said: “I am pleased that common sense has prevailed.
“This is something the Labour group has opposed all the way along, storing up trouble for the future and the Lib Dems have done a total U-turn because of Express & Echo campaigning and the opposition by us. It is a panic reaction.”
Leader of the Conservative group Yolonda Henson, said: “I am more delighted for the public than anything.
“It was a big mistake to even think about closing the toilets.
“Exeter would have got a bad name. Why should people think about coming here if we could not provide the most basic of facilities?
“We now need to have a serious look at all those toilets and I would not advocate closing any of them until we have had a proper look at the implications.”
The closure plan had also been attacked for the impact it could have on the vulnerable, disabled and elderly.
Charities representing these groups had expressed strong concerns about the proposals.
After being told of the reprieve, Martyn Rogers, the director of Age Concern in Exeter, said: “I think this is good news for common sense. A whole lot of groups of people rely on good provision of public toilets in the city. I think the very fact some of the ones most well used were targeted for closure shows this would have had a real impact.
“It is really great news the city council has listened to the concerns of the citizens of Exeter who responded in their hundreds. Well done to the Echo.”
Nick Hall, of Headway Exeter, a charity that supports people with brain injuries, said: “Congratulations to the Echo on its campaign. It is very good news that now people with brain injuries will be able to use the city centre more easily knowing that public toilets will be available for them to use.”
Member of the public also expressed their delight at the outcome.
Julia Clarke, 64, of Whipton, said: “That is fantastic news and I am over the moon.
“I have a severely disabled daughter and public toilets are very important to her. She can only communicate by facial expressions and we can be in a cafe one minute and then go outside and she will need the toilet, which has happened, and we need to know that one is nearby. Disabled people are getting more out into the community but things have to be accessible to them.
“This should never have come up in the first place. People accept there have got to be cuts but public toilets are essential and what sort of message would this have sent to visitors?
“I am so pleased this has been resolved.”













20 Comments
View all
by Simon, Exeter
Wednesday, February 03 2010, 4:08PM
“The toilets are safe but we are not, as long as everyone can go to toilets thats fine, just a shame about people getting attacked by making cuts in the CCTV Control Centre. Crime rates up and citizen safety down what an awful combination. Thanks Exeter City Council you have failed us again!”
by Bob, Exeter
Wednesday, February 03 2010, 3:38PM
“The EandE did what they needed to. Bring it to peoples attention. That's it/ That's all.
They should not get any credit. They look to sensationalise everything. How many vouchers were handed in? what 300-400. What a majority!!
So cuts. Cuts are coming we have to accept it.
So what do we cut.?
I have no issue with street lighting being switch off in the very late hours. How many people do you see walking about at 3-5am? not many
Lets talk about putting in a 10/20p charge for using public toilets.
Lets increase the car parking charges, just 10p an hour.
Lets charge people for parking more than 1 car outside their houses.
Lets cut the number of sick days council workers take - the ones we pay for.
Lets only have our rubbish and recyling collected one every 2 weeks.
Lets stop investing in our schools and city infrastructure/
Lets stop having nice arty events and festivals which are free to everyone.
Lets stop having our pavents cleaned and our parks patrolled.
Lets not filling the pot-hole ridden roads.
Get it. Cuts are going to come and I would rather cut the toliets than cut some of the othere services which we pay the council to provide.
Oh, lets not have the roads and ppavements gritted.”
by dilys baldwin, exeter
Wednesday, February 03 2010, 8:26AM
“great news on u turn
once again L.D take easy options instead of looking in other areas.Staff will be looking at job cuts now L.D attack them with loss of income.”
by Jimmy, Crediton
Tuesday, February 02 2010, 7:49PM
“I knew this would cause a stink now Exeter you know what you have to do "pay back time" when the elections come around, just for their ignorance.....”
by Mark, Exeter
Tuesday, February 02 2010, 7:45PM
“Great news re the toilets,its a shame the Lib Dems cant work there magic with the cctv control centre,it will be great to use the toilets but lets hope you dont get mugged or attacked outside as the cameras will be on tour,as the cctv operatives will be down the job centre come on people of exeter now lets have a real campaign save your cctv control room!!!”