Residents who have lost 15 meters of garden act on cliff erosion fear

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, April 21, 2011
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

CLIFF-TOP residents in Sidmouth who have lost up to 15 metres of their gardens have taken matters into their own hands.

Residents who live in 12 properties on Cliff Road say their properties are threatened because of cliff erosion. They have submitted a planning application for a protection scheme to East Devon District Council.

The residents have funded the £10,000 application themselves which is for a 240-metre long, 4.5-metre high rock revetment at the base of the cliffs near Pennington Point at the mouth of the River Sid.

The scheme could cost around £900,000 of public money.

Residents say their homes could fall over the cliff face within 15 years if action is not taken soon.

They say the erosion was accelerated from around 2002 after the installation of rock groynes along the seafront in 1995.

Resident, Peter Hand, 71, said: "In the last 10 years the cliffs have eroded more than they have in the last 100 years. We've been campaigning for over a decade for something to be done about the rate of erosion.

"When the rock groynes were put in, the current in the bay changed. The shingle, that used to move back and forwards, gets taken away by the tides and doesn't replenish.

"As a result, the waves began to hit the cliffs at the eastern end of Sidmouth far more.

"When I first moved here, a footpath ran along the cliff tops at the bottom of our gardens, but that has now disappeared.

"We're worried about who will be liable if someone is killed on the beach below because it's our land not the council's anymore."

Paul Griew, 63, said residents were also concerned the cliff erosion at the mouth of the river may mean the town and sewage works become flooded.

He said: "We're probably doing the council's work for them, but if this is what it takes to kick start the process then so be it. In 2007 the cliffs were eroding at about two metres a year and by 2009 it was an average of three – four metres a year. One resident lost 10 metres of his garden in 2002 alone.

"And I've lost 15 metres in the last two years.

"There is a real and immediate risk to our homes – if it continues like this at the current rate we'll have to leave our homes in 15 years.

"And one of the country's busiest footpaths, which is used by around 250,000 people a year, will disappear.

"This could have a disastrous affect on tourism and the economy of Sidmouth.

An East Devon District Council spokesman said: "Until recently, coastal protection policy did not allow for this section of coastline to be considered for the kind of works proposed in this application.

"Now an area to the east of the River Sid is part of a 'unit' in the latest version of the national Shoreline Management Plan. This unit is earmarked for 'managed realignment'. This could mean a scheme of some description might be possible here, but it will be subject to many checks and balances before it could go ahead.

"There is a tension between coastal protection and allowing natural processes of erosion, and there are strong lobbies for both approaches.

"Any scheme will have to pass the scrutiny of Natural England and the Environment Agency."

8
Tweet this article
Report

8 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by tim, exeter

    Saturday, April 23 2011, 12:11PM

    “'Resident, Peter Hand, 71, said: "In the last 10 years the cliffs have eroded more than they have in the last 100 years'.

    So the residents were aware of the cliffs having eroded for the last 100 years therefore, unless they are all over 100, they knew of the problem when purchasing the properties and that risk of erosion would have discounted and been taken into account in the purchase price.

    If you take a risk it is either because you are stupid or prepared to take the consequences others are not willing to take - either way it is your fault.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Nick, Devon

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 10:54PM

    “It is not unreasonable to expect that the government (from Sidmouth Council upwards) should take reasonable steps to prevent people's houses falling into the sea. The west cliff at Sidmouth has a revettment which prevents erosion, and it is quite feasible to do the same on the east cliff. So far the council has fannied around and done nothing. It's time they came up with a plan.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by James, Exeter

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 6:03PM

    “Well, Gribble, if you want to move to Sidmouth to escape the seagulls there are plenty of desirable cliff-top homes going cheap there - well, going anyway!

    Mind you, I would have though a 3-4 square metre snapshot section of cliff face might be rather slender evidence for the general absence of seagulls. :)”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by peter, Exeter

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 3:42PM

    “Ok so in 15 years time their properties will be worthless, obviously nice having cliff top views but a bit of a draw back with the land disappearing. 12 properties at a very conservative £250,000 each equals £3 million. Now someone is to blame so why not blame the council & expect them to put it all right.. One can either let them fall over the edge, or expect the residents to save themselves as views like that are expensive. £100,000 each should cover it......lol”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by GRIBBLE, COWICK ST

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 3:07PM

    “When you look a little close at the clifftop in the background......................................................................................something is missing NO SEAGULLS..........because they are all living in cowick st making my life HELL !
    they think they have got problems in Sidmouth !”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Trudy Gloyn, Mandrake Road Exeter

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 3:01PM

    “---"should have gone to....spec-savers ;)”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by they must have seen you coming, Honiton East Devon

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 1:41PM

    “Knowing the area and history of erosion on the Jurrasic coast.
    why buy a house by the cliffs in Sidmouth ?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by GRIBBLE, COWICK ST

    Thursday, April 21 2011, 1:20PM

    “My advice
    if you want it would be if you have any garden gnomes ,remove them from the back garden and find a new home for them in the shade in the front garden.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters