We need to stop bashing farmers

Trusted article source icon
Friday, July 15, 2011
Profile image for Exeter Express and Echo

Exeter Express and Echo

JUSTIN Kerswell demonstrates his ignorance of social behaviour patterns of badgers in the wild in his letter (Territorial badgers not spreading TB, letters, July 13). He states that Melanie Squires' assertion that "TB is spreading to new areas via badgers..." is wrong and asks how they are supposed to be doing this? Well, anybody who has ever had an association with the countryside will understand that badgers are extremely social animals and live in social groups.

However, when these groups get too large for social order and for the health of the sett, the new younger ones leave to "spread to new areas" to form new social groups and the process is repeated again and again.

Cattle, on the other hand, are always managed in herds on the same farms. I therefore think it is pretty obvious which group has the greatest chance of spreading TB.

Anybody who has ever worked in the countryside either for wildlife organisations or as farmers (and I have done both) will understand that the countryside requires balance to operate and the moment you alter that balance in favour of one species or another you risk upsetting this delicate balance.

In my working career I have yet to meet a single farmer who doesn't like or appreciate wildlife, and if they could achieve it, they would welcome healthy badgers on their farms, but they do run businesses producing food.

Consumers should know that unless we do something about this problem soon, we will run out of time and options for farmers to respond to the real challenges of producing wholesome food from this fantastic region of ours. We are entering a very dangerous and delicate phase in world food production and this region has a massive role to play in that.

Let's back a trial involving a cull of badgers in a large enough area of the Westcountry to be effective and let's keep an open mind on the results.

We need to get on with the job of producing good quality food and looking after our countryside and stop bashing those who do just that.

John Sheaves

Ottery St Mary

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for GRIBBLE666

    by GRIBBLE666

    Friday, July 15 2011, 4:02PM

    “let's stop bashing our farmers
    and start bashing our bishops
    far more fun”

  • Profile image for 2ladybugs

    by 2ladybugs

    Friday, July 15 2011, 3:08PM

    “Killing all badgers when not all badgers have the disease is ludicrous. It's like saying kill all cattle just because a couple of farms have the disease. Until a genuine, fair, solution to this problem is found the movement of all cattle should be put on hold as this seems to be the underlying problem. Not all farmers are careful with their cattle. Cows from an infected herd where I live got through the hedge into another farm where they have no TB. So don't just keep blaming wild animals for the problems.”

  • Profile image for franklee1

    by franklee1

    Friday, July 15 2011, 2:41PM

    “Whilst there is conflicting scientific evidence we cannot cull such beautiful creatures. If the cull carried out in Ireland had been more successful there may be greater argument, however this is not the case.
    We need an effective test for bovine TB that will establish the extent of infection caused by transportation. I am not yet convinced that the cows dont infect the badgers.”

  • Profile image for RioandThelma

    by RioandThelma

    Friday, July 15 2011, 11:07AM

    “You don't have to be "Brain of Britain" to realise that if you kill every badger, say, in Devon and Cornwall the spread of bovine TB BY badgers will be eliminated in Devon and Cornwall.

    It does not mean that bovine TB in Devon and Cornwall will be eliminated but no doubt it will be less; how much less - that will be just an educated guess.

    I understand that since more rigorous checks are being carried out on animal movements bovine TB has reduced but there are still reports of irresponsible farmers and dealers flouting the restrictions”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters